Saturday, 06 September 2008 | frontiermagazine.net
frontiermagazine.net
Only the really interesting stuff
Home arrow Reviews arrow Television arrow Doctor Who: The Unquiet Dead
Doctor Who: The Unquiet Dead Print
Written by Jeremy   
Thursday, 28 April 2005
Episode 1.03

Doctor Who: The Unquiet DeadThe Doctor and Rose arrive in Cardiff on Christmas Eve in the 19th century – though the Doctor thought he was landing in Naples. They arrive just in time to witness strange events at a show of Charles Dickens – an old woman, supposedly dead, expunges a gaseous creature that cries and shrieks until it disappears. The old woman is quickly swept up by an undertaker and his assistant and, when Rose tries to stop them, they drug and capture her too.

The Doctor and Dickens pursue the undertaker back to his place of business, where the truth is soon discovered – the ghostly creatures taking over the bodies of the dead are in fact something else, something that needs the Doctor’s help.

The setup for this episode is beautifully handled. While the setting could have been anywhere English, the buildings and the snow and the extras all make us feel like we are in Wales of the time. A nice touch is how the Doctor tells Rose to change into clothes more appropriate for the time to stop her attracting attention, but when she points out his own clothing he is offended – “I changed my jumper!”

Also a nice touch is how Rose bullies her way in front of the Doctor to be first out the door. Like a young girl on a grand adventure, she wants to be the first to experience it. Her joy is well played by Billie Piper.

Simon Callow, legend of British theatre, television and film, plays Charles Dickens as an aging, tired man who thinks there is nothing more in the world that would surprise him. Of course when the Doctor suddenly arrives and drags him off into an adventure, suddenly a whole universe of possibilities is open to him. Callow, much to his credit, does not ride over the other players in this episode and keeps Dickens to what he should be – a supporting, guest character. He handles it deftly and smartly.

Effects, once again, are top notch. The gaseous apparitions bring up memories of Raiders of the Lost Ark, which is a good thing, given the mistake the Doctor makes regarding them.

And that is a major point of this episode. In the original series, the Doctor rarely made mistakes. Maybe little ones, to create tension or a cliff-hanger, but never was the climax of a whole story hung on his error in judgment.  In “The Unquiet Dead” we see the Doctor is fallible – he’s not right, all the time, though he likes to think he is. And while later in the episode the raging dead people does seem a bit camp and lacks tension – especially with the makeup – we are really there to see the Doctor realize his mistake and realize that his decisions can directly cost innocent lives. In a later episode, we see how this affects him - and makes him question his own judgment.

All together a well written, acted and presented self-contained story.

- Jeremy Sadler
 
< Prev   Next >
Go to top of page Go to top of page